Why "10 best things to do in New York" is only the starting point

By Francesca Roland, Marketing & Content Director, with Jamie White, SEO Director, Platform 195
Google now draws a clear line between commodity and non-commodity content. For travel brands selling the same trips as everyone else, it's an important line and one worth understanding.
Travel has always had a bit of a sameness problem, we've written about it before, and it isn't changing any time soon. The same hotels, flights and destinations sit on dozens of sites at similar prices, and the content around them tends to look alike too. Search "things to do in New York" and you'll find near-identical lists from OTAs, tour operators, review sites and publishers.
I'm not knocking those lists, I've written more than my fair share of them over the years. They still have an important job to do, and there are good reasons we create them for the brands we work with. But if you're an established brand with years of that content already on your site, Google's latest guidance makes it clear that more of the same won't set you apart.
I sat down with Jamie White, our SEO Director, to dig deeper into what it means for travel brands and where they should focus.
So what is non-commodity content?
Google's guide to optimising for generative AI features in Search, published in May 2026, splits content into two camps. Commodity content is built on common knowledge anyone could have written, like Google's own example, "7 Tips for First-Time Homebuyers".
Non-commodity content brings an expert or first-hand take that goes beyond what's already out there, and Google says it's likely to matter more for your presence in AI search than anything else in the guide.
The principle isn't new, Google has been pushing for people-first content for years, but the bar has risen.
"What's changed in the past year or so is adding real uniqueness to it, through expert commentary, case studies, numbers and stats," Jamie told me.
That's why I'd never advise a brand to stop producing the familiar destination content, and Jamie agrees.
"I don't think people should steer away from producing that content where it serves a purpose. What Google is trying to discourage is having 100 versions of the same piece of content," says Jamie.
The reassuring part is that nobody needs to start from scratch. From Google's point of view, optimising for AI search is still SEO.
Travel makes this harder, and more important
So, if everyone is selling the same trips to the same hotels in the same destinations, how do you create anything non-commodity at all? I'd argue a level playing field is exactly where this matters most, and Jamie explains it nicely.
"Where the product is largely equal, that's where non-commodity content comes into play in a much more prominent way. We want people to come to us because we offer X, Y and Z, and here's the evidence of where we've done it."
Price still matters, but when several brands compete on similar prices for similar trips, it gives an AI tool very little to tell them apart.
Add to this that people are searching differently too, "Holidays to New York" becomes a conversation with ChatGPT or Gemini about neighbourhoods and hotels. So what gets surfaced?
"A brand isn't going to be surfaced because it has a top 10 article. It's more likely to be based on real-life user experiences, case studies, whether they've sent a member of the team out to assess the hotels. If brands can evidence that, they're going to reap the rewards over those that don't," says Jamie.
You already have the raw material
This is where travel retailers have a real advantage. A publisher can describe a destination, but the brand that sold the trip has a direct relationship with the people who went, which makes it far easier to gather their stories, reviews and photos. Jamie suggested a few places to start.
- Customer reviews and photos on the holiday page itself, alongside the hotel's stock imagery.
- Real trip stories, like one couple's week in New York, where they ate and what they'd do again. "It's something no other brand could do, because they are your customer," Jamie said.
- Your team's first-hand expertise, from a product manager who has inspected a resort to a specialist who knows family holidays inside out.
- A clear specialism, because a brand that commits to being the expert in something naturally produces content with its own fingerprints on it.
There's one firm rule, it has to be real.
"I'd really not encourage anyone to make this stuff up," Jamie adds, and Google's guide notes that chasing inauthentic mentions across the web is less useful than it might look.
More content won't fix it
It's tempting to answer AI search by publishing more, with a page for every version of a question. But Google warns against exactly that, and mass-producing pages to game rankings can breach its spam policies.
"If one piece of content sells your service so well that anyone landing on it would be sold immediately, you don't need pieces two, three, four and five," Jamie said.
There's no magic ratio either. A new brand still needs broad destination and product pages to show what it offers. For established brands, that foundation is usually already there, so the opportunity is in what you build on top of it.
Frequently asked questions
What is non-commodity content?
Content that brings an expert or first-hand perspective beyond common knowledge. Google says it is likely to influence your visibility in AI search more than anything else in its guide.
Should travel brands stop publishing "top 10" destination content?
No. Familiar destination content still has a job to do, especially for newer brands. Google's concern is many versions of the same piece, so established brands get more from building on what they already have.
Do travel brands need a separate strategy for AI search?
No. Google treats optimising for its AI features as SEO, so the priority is content only your brand could publish, built into your existing search strategy.
A five-minute test
So, how does your brand fare in this new environment? Jamie recommends a simple and easy assessment to kick things off.
"Read some of the content on your website and ask, could it have been written by any other brand in the market? If the answer is largely yes, you're probably not adding your unique take."
None of this needs a separate AI strategy, what it needs is content only your brand could publish, built into the search strategy you already have.
If you'd like a second pair of eyes on your existing content or SEO strategy, our Amplify team (Jamie included) works with travel brands to spot where their content blends in and build the pieces that help them stand out. Get in touch, we'd love to help.
Ready to grow your brand?
Whether you're just starting out or looking to take your retail media and marketing to the next level, Platform 195 is here to help.

.jpeg)





















.jpeg)






































